I remembered to get Evil Jhudorah today. I decided to get it for all 5 of my accounts.

In each account I have at least 1,000 items in the gallery. And in every case she asked for something that was in another account's gallery.

Poeia's was in ground_floor's gallery
nytcrossword's & ground_floor's were in bargain_basement's gallery
4th_floor's was in nytcrossword's
bargain_basement's was in 4th_floor's

I did a lot of logging on, sending to neofriend and logging off