fisherbunny
Member
Reged: 21/08/2005
Posts: 438
|
|
After read all 5 chapters on the Cyodrake's Gaze Comics & visited the Map Room, We are allowed to "Spill the bean".
I've actually guessed (after reread the comics in English and Chinese language) who pushed Hoban the navigator. Here are something that I think it's suspicious:
(1) Linae claimed Anshu and her talked about "how bad are their foods recently". While Anshu told us Linae and he was talking about her medical thingy.
(2) Linae claimed she helped Anshu fixing leaks below deck before the storm ends while Anshu mentioned nothing about he has been fixing with Linae.
(3) Linae said she assume Anshu went downstair to get ready for 'Medical supplies' while later she said she helped Anshu with fixing leaks......if she really did fixed leaks with Anshu then why she said Medical supplies 
(4) Seems like Linae is the only character who keeps saying Hoban has rotten/bad luck.
(5) even on Chapter 3, Bonju said he heard Hoban complained Linae kept saying Hoban brings bad luck.
(6) Chapter 5, Anshu said he heard someone was arguing with Hoban when he was fixing the leaks in below deck. If Anshu is really below deck, who would argue with Hoban? Especially Hoban seems annoyed with Linae.
anymore suspicious points you could name out??
I have voted Linae, in my opinion she could be the one, but I want to hear more theories from your points of view. I thought Bonju is quite suspicous too but only if Linae had lesser suspicious arrows pointing towards her, then I could have chosen Bonju.
Bonju was saying he has been washing dishes and yet how come he had time to go to storeroom to take anything as Kentari said? Bonju himself also he took a knife to replace with his own knife... but while washing dishes?! eek... I smell some lies from Bonju  well I still voted my vote to Linae though.
Tell me who you have voted to  gives me reasons why? :D
|
neostuff246
Member
Reged: 02/04/2005
Posts: 4440
Loc: The Ninja Bunny Archipalego
|
|
I like Linae, so I hope it isn't her. Bonju seems pretty suspiscious. Kentari seems so innocent, that I think TNT might be tricking us, and he pushed Hoban. Anshu seems suspiscious to me, for whatever reason. However, I decided to vote for Bonju.
--------------------
|
sleijo
Member
Reged: 06/03/2005
Posts: 5
|
|
He didn't.
Like my better half, Jorophose suggested at PinkPT's forum, he jumped off the boat to become the esophagor after marrying Edna.
|
leader_monique
Member
Reged: 22/03/2006
Posts: 731
Loc: Lost in my thoughts
|
|
Quote:
He didn't.
Like my better half, Jorophose suggested at PinkPT's forum, he jumped off the boat to become the esophagor after marrying Edna.
o_O?!
--
Anyway.. I vote for Linae.. for the same reasons fisherbunny pointed out..
--------------------
|| candelen_08 || leader_monique || keropi080 || keropi_escapades ||
I'm ready! I'm ready! I'm ready!
= LiveJournal = Youtube = Neopets =
|
wpgmom
Member
Reged: 23/03/2005
Posts: 26
Loc: Winnipeg, Mb CANADA
|
|
I voted linae........ if she thought he was bad luck she may have just wanted him off the boat 
--------------------
"Reality is for those who lack imagination."
|
cecethegreat
Member
Reged: 02/09/2006
Posts: 1
Loc: canada
|
|
i think the chief did. O_0  
|
bookie94
Member
Reged: 20/02/2005
Posts: 173
Loc: On my computer chair.
|
|
Linae. She's evil.
But pretty. Like most girl-villians. 
|
sleijo
Member
Reged: 06/03/2005
Posts: 5
|
|
Quote:
Quote:
He didn't.
Like my better half, Jorophose suggested at PinkPT's forum, he jumped off the boat to become the esophagor after marrying Edna.
o_O?!
Fine.
Don't beleive me.
But when I get it published in the neotimes, who will be laughing now?
|
neopetsroxsthe
Member
Reged: 12/04/2005
Posts: 2761
Loc: Loompaland
|
|
This ploit is very confusing. Can someone fill me in on this map thing?
--------------------
I make banners! PM me to get one specially made!
I am the proud owner of a Darigan Hissi, Garlic Jubjub, Desert Usul and a Pink Poogle.
My Scrollery Gallery
Wishlist:All the Scrolls for my Gallery.
Bla, bla, bla.....!
|
Seren
Member
Reged: 03/08/2004
Posts: 2164
Loc: England
|
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
He didn't.
Like my better half, Jorophose suggested at PinkPT's forum, he jumped off the boat to become the esophagor after marrying Edna.
o_O?!
Fine.
Don't beleive me.
But when I get it published in the neotimes, who will be laughing now?
Lol!
Aaaaanyway  I voted Linae, and I found enough info to make an educated guess at where and when, but I haven't the foggiest where Hoban is now... does anyone have any idea how we're meant to work this out?
|
wpgmom
Member
Reged: 23/03/2005
Posts: 26
Loc: Winnipeg, Mb CANADA
|
|
I dont know much about it either but I figured why not put in what I think and see what happens......better to take a chance. 
--------------------
"Reality is for those who lack imagination."
|
woodbine
Member
Reged: 18/08/2006
Posts: 354
Loc: The Computer
|
|
I don't know... But I'm guessing Bonju...
--------------------
|
leogems
Member
Reged: 29/07/2006
Posts: 34
|
|
I'm not sure who did it. I do think Bonju might have been lying about seeing Hoban the third time. The reason I think that is because the first time he saw Hoban was when Hoban was talking to Kentari about Linae calling him a bad omen. So, he could have overheard that conversation, and repeated it in his part of the story.
I'm sure he's lying about something, but I don't know if Bonju did it.
I wonder about the time too. Lots of people are thinking it was towards the end of the storm. It seems to me that if you'd want to push someone off, you'd do it while the storm is strong, not when it's slowing down. Less likely to be noticed. Just a couple of thoughts.
--------------------
|
fisherbunny
Member
Reged: 21/08/2005
Posts: 438
|
|
leogems, interesting opinions. I do believe Bonju is hiding something too.. thanks for sharing, leogems & everyone.
|
Kaetyn2
Member
Reged: 22/01/2003
Posts: 2156
Loc: Bouncing off padded walls.
|
|
Quote:
He didn't.
Like my better half, Jorophose suggested at PinkPT's forum, he jumped off the boat to become the esophagor after marrying Edna.
*creates an army of o_0's* Um...OK. *applause* Nice theory. xD
Personally, though, I don't really know, so I just guessed Bonju. He seems sort of suspicious in my opinion...
--------------------
Insert stuff here. YAAAAY!
|
blissis06
Member
Reged: 29/01/2006
Posts: 126
Loc: Faerieland
|
|
I don't think it was the medical guy, or the weapons master--(No, i'm not good with these wierd names) I agree, both Linae and Bonjou sound suspicious. I need to look over the comic again.
--------------------
This is my signature!
|
woodbine
Member
Reged: 18/08/2006
Posts: 354
Loc: The Computer
|
|
I think Bonju is a high level suspect...
--------------------
|
wildcats526
Member
Reged: 20/08/2006
Posts: 2
Loc: Shopping for Packrat items!!
|
|
i voted for linae too, although it was an educated guess! 
--------------------
My Goal: Packrat Avatar! Total number of items: 504/1000
|
leogems
Member
Reged: 29/07/2006
Posts: 34
|
|
Thanks!
Another thought has come to mind, after looking at the comics again. What if the whole thing was an accident? The guilty party might not even know they did it.
With a fierce storm going on, how hard would it be, to bump into something or someone, and not even notice? You're busy trying to tie stuff down, and keep the ship afloat, right? Plus, the crashing waves, fierce winds, and booming thunder, could muffle any screams for help from a fallen comrade.
That would also lead one to suspect that they all might be lying. If you were being questioned as a possible suspect, and knew you were innocent, wouldn't you try to point the finger at someone else? Especially when everyone knows that you had enough motives to have committed the crime.
--------------------
|
woodbine
Member
Reged: 18/08/2006
Posts: 354
Loc: The Computer
|
|
I voted for Bonju.
--------------------
|
Alchemist
Member
Reged: 16/09/2003
Posts: 1467
Loc: United Kingdom
|
|
Voted? Voted where?
--------------------
Wisest is He that Knows He Does Not Know.
"Beauty is in the eye of the Beholder--although sometimes it is necessary to give a stupid or misinformed beholder a black eye" ~Miss Piggy
The J Gallery
Wishlist
The missing faerie trading cards for my neodeck
Grey Faerie Card / Illusen The Earth Faerie / Jhudora the Dark Faerie / Rainbow Fountain Card
Need A Premium Referral? Contact Me
|
nephele
Member
Reged: 17/07/2005
Posts: 11
|
|
To vote, go to the ship, talk to the captain and click on spill the beans.
|
Seren
Member
Reged: 03/08/2004
Posts: 2164
Loc: England
|
|
Quote:
Voted? Voted where?
http://www.neopets.com/cg_captain.phtml
|
puffkins2000
Unwell Pirate
Reged: 19/12/2002
Posts: 6047
Loc: Anxiously awaiting CJS
|
|
Ah, darn... I just made random guesses. *doesn't have good enough flash to watch the comics and all* So... I'm lost. XD
Anyway, here were my guesses:
Who pushed Hoban? Kentari
When did he fall? 2:00
Where on the ship did he fall? starboard railing
Where is Hoban now? F6
Do you like Hoban's hat? yes, it's very stylish
Yes, of course I LOOVVEE his hat. XD I want one just like it. *steals his*
--------------------
Wishlist | Most Wanted | LJ
*Angelpuss lover*
Wishes: any Pirate things on wishie, Eyrie MP, Pirate & Darigan P/B
|
taradith
Member
Reged: 25/04/2003
Posts: 2179
Loc: Brightvale
|
|
I thought Hoban was the shiftiest of them all and still think he jumped. Failing that, Linae is the most obvious choice, but it seems too easy. I'm actually picking Kentari because he's the only one who really didn't bother with any sort of an alibi. He also clearly thinks Hoban is lazy, and Hoban also looks the most evil in Kentari's intro. The fact that Kentari never had an argument (or even a conversation) with Hoban is a bit suspicous too.
(That said, it's probably Linae. )
I'm not in love with Hoban's hat, but I DO like how he, unlike most of the recent Aisha, generally has his eyes closed. It's fine that they're occasionally open, but most the plot Aishas have wide-open eyes when the pets themselves don't, which I don't like.
--------------------
You can call me Taradith.
Pet the wrong gender? You may be able to fix it, risk-free! Or visit my Lab Adoption Diary
First-person narration is still hard.
|
leogems
Member
Reged: 29/07/2006
Posts: 34
|
|
I voted for Kentari too. Linae is just too easy a choice for me, and I feel they almost want you to vote for her or Bonju, so I don't know.
Kentari seems like the cleanest guy out of the group, which makes him more suspicious.
As they say, "The one you expect the lease, expect the most."
--------------------
|
VernaxEater
Member
Reged: 15/03/2005
Posts: 1044
Loc: Hiding in the Shadows
|
|
I voted for Kentari. There is not a lot of information on what he was doing at that time. I also suspect that he really just jumped.
--------------------
Enter my lair, but please, don't get stuck in the web.
|
puffkins2000
Unwell Pirate
Reged: 19/12/2002
Posts: 6047
Loc: Anxiously awaiting CJS
|
|
I actually... don't know what Hoban looks like. x_x Nor his hat. I was making a joke there. XD
I really just randomly guessed. It'll be surprising if I'm right though. XD
--------------------
Wishlist | Most Wanted | LJ
*Angelpuss lover*
Wishes: any Pirate things on wishie, Eyrie MP, Pirate & Darigan P/B
|
Winniethepooh
Member
Reged: 07/05/2006
Posts: 146
Loc: Swindon, England
|
|
Haha. I voted Bonju, he has an evil look in his eye
And it WAS Bonju!! Haha
--------------------
I love Kougra's and Xweetok's Right.
If they did a Kougra+Xweetok as a pet I would buy it.
|
Seren
Member
Reged: 03/08/2004
Posts: 2164
Loc: England
|
|
Well, I was wrong, as were many others here, but.. does it even matter? I haven't seen any mention of the guesses since the answer was released, and no sign of any hindrance to the plot...
Maybe it will matter when the scores are tallied and prizes released.. but so far, no?
|
StarryDraik
Tinsel Terror
Reged: 05/02/2003
Posts: 8987
Loc: Upstate
|
|
I hope that TNT merely expected us to make a guess, as there couldn't possibly be enough evidence for anyone to logically have chosen Bonju, short of the 'suspicious' glint.
What a troubled blumaroo though
--------------------
Avatarlog: http://avatar.starried.net
All about item ID numbers and how to get them!
|
neostuff246
Member
Reged: 02/04/2005
Posts: 4440
Loc: The Ninja Bunny Archipalego
|
|
I had a feeling that it was bonju..... It looked odd when he put on an overly innocent expresion in the comic though.
Hoban almost seems to be smiling with happiness in the first frame of his story of what happened, where he's yelling at the other crew members. Odd.
--------------------
|
woodbine
Member
Reged: 18/08/2006
Posts: 354
Loc: The Computer
|
|
Yes, Bonju was a high level suspect...
--------------------
|
neopetsroxsthe
Member
Reged: 12/04/2005
Posts: 2761
Loc: Loompaland
|
|
I was wrong about where he fell off and who pushed him. Humph.
Now that this plot is over-ish, where are our AP Prizes?
--------------------
I make banners! PM me to get one specially made!
I am the proud owner of a Darigan Hissi, Garlic Jubjub, Desert Usul and a Pink Poogle.
My Scrollery Gallery
Wishlist:All the Scrolls for my Gallery.
Bla, bla, bla.....!
|
leogems
Member
Reged: 29/07/2006
Posts: 34
|
|
Oh, well, got that one wrong. 
--------------------
|
puffkins2000
Unwell Pirate
Reged: 19/12/2002
Posts: 6047
Loc: Anxiously awaiting CJS
|
|
Previous
Index
Next
Threaded
Edit
Reply
Quote
