Definitely send a message to Support about it. I had the exact same problem a couple months ago and it took a while but they finally fixed it up and gave me my sub. Make sure you send your Paypal receipt number and when you bought it and hopefully your problem will be solved quickly.
NeoItems.net is an unofficial fan site for Neopets.com users. NeoPets and all related names, characters, logos and indicia are trademarks of NeoPets, Inc., Copyright 2003. All rights reserved. Used with permission.